Medical malpractice claims often hinge on the legal concept of “negligence,” which is central to establishing liability in such cases.
Duty of Care
In medical malpractice claims, courts recognize that a doctor or hospital owes a duty of care to the patient. This duty arises from the doctor-patient relationship, where the physician is expected to provide treatment that meets a certain standard of care.
Hospitals can also be held liable for the negligence of their employees under the principle of vicarious liability.
Standard of Care
The crux of many malpractice cases revolves around the standard of care. This standard is determined by what a reasonable medical professional would do in similar circumstances. Expert testimony is often required to establish whether the defendant’s actions fell below this standard. Without such expert evidence, cases may be dismissed before reaching trial.
Plaintiff must secure a medical expert’s opinion:
That identifies the standard of care required in the circumstances of the plaintiff’s needs.
That the doctor’s and/or hospital’s conduct fell below the required standard of care.
That the injuries and/or losses suffered by the plaintiff were as a result of the hospital and/or doctor failing below the standard of care.
That the losses suffered by the plaintiff were reasonably foreseeable to someone in the doctor’s and/or hospital’s position.
Informed Consent
Before administering medical treatment, doctors must ensure patients give informed consent. This means patients must understand the risks, benefits, and alternatives to the proposed treatment. Courts assess whether consent was truly informed and whether the harm suffered by the patient was within the scope of the risks disclosed. Informed consent is evaluated on a case-by-case basis and is crucial in determining liability.
The courts have held that informed consent is a fact-specific issue that must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
Videto v Kennedy
The Ontario Court of Appeal described the considerations surrounding informed consent as follows:
A finding that a doctor’s conduct fell below the standard of care does not necessarily mean that the other elements of negligence are proven. Conversely, a finding that informed consent was obtained does not necessarily mean that the doctor was not negligent with respect to the ultimate loss sustained by the plaintiff.
Inherent Risks
Patients are aware that medical procedures carry inherent risks. Courts consider whether the harm suffered by the patient was a foreseeable consequence of the procedure for which consent was given. This assessment helps determine if the doctor can be held liable for the resulting injury.
Example
Damages
Finally, for a successful negligence claim, the plaintiff must prove all elements of negligence, including duty of care, breach of duty, causation, and damages. If any element is not sufficiently proven, the claim may fail, and damages need not be assessed.
Most malpractice lawyers turn away 90% of potential because it is evident that the case does not meet all the necessary elements. Due to the rigorous requirements and complexities involved, many potential malpractice claims do not proceed beyond initial evaluation by lawyers, as they may lack sufficient evidence to establish negligence. Each case requires careful consideration of the specific facts and legal principles involved to determine its viability in court.
This blog post does not constitute legal advice and was written solely to provide information. If you would like to consult with a lawyer about the issues raised in this post, please contact Empel Law Professional Corporation at 416-500-1937.
